Week 1 Post 1
"What part of 'know' don't you understand?"
·
Cogency
o
Definition: the quality of appealing to reason
o
A cogent argument makes logical sense
o
Example:
|
Cogent Argument |
Non-cogent Argument |
|
“I have a good chance of being selected for this job because I
have extensive experience in this field, and I am well qualified” |
“I have a good chance of being selected for this job, because I
have elderly parents who I support financially, and their care is very
expensive” |
·
Argument Structure
o
PremisesàConclusion
§
If an argument makes it from the PREMISE to the
CONCLUSION in a logical path, then the argument is VALID and SOUND, which means
it is COGENT
o
Definitions & Examples
|
Premise |
A proposition that we assume to be
true for the purpose of building an argument |
If a plant
has green leaves, |
|
Conclusion |
The end point of our reasoning, the
thing we are trying to prove in an argument |
then it is healthy |
|
Valid |
When the conclusion follows logically
from the premise |
This argument is valid because green
leaves is a logical justification |
|
Sound |
When the argument is valid AND the
premises are really true |
This argument is sound because the
plant actually does have green leaves |
·
Identifying
Arguments
o
In everyday conversation, argument structures
aren’t as clear; they could be: “Premise, premise, conclusion”
, “Conclusion,
premise,
premise”,
etc
o
Ex: Some legal actions are immoral. This
follows because some legal actions are unfair, but no moral
actions are unfair.”
o
Ex: Brisbane has a larger population than Toowoomba,
and Toowoomba
has more people than Gatton, so Brisbane is larger than Gatton”
·
What is knowledge?
o
A justified true belief
o
Epistemology- the theory or study of knowledge
o Things
to think about:
§
Could we get by with standards of proof or
evidence and not a definition of knowledge?
§
Could the definition of knowledge be something
we learn by seeing examples of it rather than having a unified concept?
§
Could it be that there are different notions of
knowledge for different human pursuits (everyday living, science, law, etc?)
and there is no unified concept?
·
Regress Objection
o One
of the arguments against the possibility of knowledge
o
Infinite asking of “how do you know that?”
o
Coherentism- the view that the justification of
a given belief lies in its forming part of a web of coherent beliefs
o
Foundationalism- the view that there are certain
truths that can be known and which serve as the basis for further knowledge
o Personal
reflection
§
What sort of things do you take to be
self-evident? Can you ever be sure of anything? I believe that self evidence is something that can only be found when
there is trust. There are certain things that most people observe to be true
that you could say are self evident, such as a shared surrounding or
experience. When having a discussion with another person, such as the example
in the video, Dave would have to just trust that Alex is not relaying false
information. and believe that her experiences are true to her, since there is
no further evidence.
·
Alternative Accounts of Knowledge
o
Counterexample- an example which disproves a
general statement or definition
o
Reliabilism- the view that knowledge comes from
reliable belief mechanisms
o
Externalism- emphasizing the external
relationships between our evidence-collecting and belief-forming mechanisms and
the world
o
Internalism- if someone knows something, there
must be an internal connection between their evidence and what they believe
o
Gettier cases- proposed counterexamples to the
definition of knowledge as justified true belief; cause problems for
externalist and reliabilist accounts of knowledge
·
Circularity/Circular Reasoning
o
When one attempts to defend sources of
justification for belief without relying on that source in the process
o
The problem with this is that in order to defend
any claim, we have to use reason
§
In order for knowledge to get off the ground, we
must assume that the sources of our beliefs are generally reliable
·
Skepticism
o Another
argument against the possibility of knowledge
o Skeptics
use a variety of techniques to raise doubt about any proposition asserted to be
true
o Can
be local or global
§ Locally:
doubt is used as a way of questioning assumptions, preconceived opinions, and
dogmatic assertions; a necessary part of rational inquiry
§ Globally:
nothing is beyond doubt because none of our beliefs can be defended as
justified
o Empiricism-
the view that all our knowledge depends on information provided through the
operation of the senses
o Skepticism
must be distinguished from ordinary incredulity
This does seem like a very fascinating class!
ReplyDelete