Week 2 Post 1

Philosophy and Critical Thinking Module 2: Mind the Explanatory Gap

·         Key Questions: How do we reason using our experiences of the world? // Can we trust an argument just because its logical? // What’s wrong with thinking deductively? // What do the words ‘necessary’ and ‘sufficient’ mean for our thinking? // How can we understand the question of identity? // How could a mind and body interact? // Can we explain the mind just in terms of how the brain works?


Conditionals and Deductive Fallacies

o   Conditional- if A is true (antecedent) à then B is true (consequent)

§  A type of argument structure

o   Affirming the consequent

§  Ex: If I am cold, it is snowing. It is snowing. Therefore I am cold. (just because ‘it is snowing’ is true, does not mean ‘I am cold is true’)

o   Denying the antecedent

§  Ex: If I am a teacher, I spend lots of time with students. I am not a teacher, therefore I do not spend lots of time with students. (just because ‘I am a teacher is false, does not imply that ‘I spend lots of time with students’ must also be false)

o   Why are these considered logical deductive fallacies? There is no logical or evidentiary connection between one event and the other; each event can occur in the absence of the other, and there is no time constraint between them.

·         Necessary and Sufficient Conditions

o   Sufficient example: If a brain is simply sufficient for a mind, then perhaps you could get a mind from a computer too.

o   Necessary example: If a brain is necessary for a mind, then whenever you find a mind you will always find a brain—but you might find a brain without a mind.

o   Necessary AND Sufficient example: If a brain is necessary and sufficient for a mind, then whenever you see one you’ll see the other.

o   Personal reflection: Do you think doing philosophy is necessary to develop wisdom, or is it sufficient. Or is it necessary and sufficient? Or maybe neither? Wisdom can most certainly be developed without philosophy because you can study something so much you become an expert, but you may never experience enough to develop wisdom. This is true for all subject matters and areas of life, but it depends on whether someone views wisdom as something that is developed only by experiences, studies, or both. The thing that makes philosophy different, is that it can help someone to understand life in  clearer way, and make greater connections to see how their knowledge can be considered wisdom. Thus philosophy is sufficient for wisdom, but depending on how you view wisdom, it may not be sufficient enough on its own.

·         Composition and Division

o   Fallacy of Composition ex: Each of the worlds greatest living novelists has contributed a chapter to this book. Therefore it is the greatest book of all time.

o   Fallacy of Division ex: The University of Queensland has a world-class philosophy department. Therefore Dave (who is from UQ’s Philosophy department) is a world-class philosopher.

o   Occur when we assume that the whole and its components must share the same properties

·         Interpretations of Cogito

o   “Cogito, ergo, sum” (I think, therefore, I am) -Descartes

§  we cannot rationally doubt our own thought, thus we cannot rationally doubt our existence

o   Examining what we can know from self-reflection and introspection leads naturally to questions about what thinking is and what the nature of the thinker, or mind, is

o   ‘I think’ doesn’t logically entail ‘I exist’ unless one assumes that the proposition: ‘Anything which thinks, exists’ is true

o   Descartes believed that thought can only occur when coming from a thinker (e.g.,  the thought ‘the universe is expanding’ could be happening even though no one is thinking it) however some philosophers such as Dave Hume, disagree

o   Contemporary philosopher Jaakko Hintikka believes that to say or think ‘I think but I don’t exist’ is pragmatically but not logically inconsistent[1]

§  Problem with this: it is not clear whether pragmatic consistency or inconsistency are sufficient grounds for concluding truth or falsity from a proposition

§  Another problem: Why is it that ‘I think’ justifies existence? Couldn’t ‘I exist’ or any other statement validating thinking do the same?

o   Personal reflection: What does it mean ‘to think’? Can animals think? I feel as though it is unfair for humans to determine whether or not animals think or are aware, because even within our own species, many struggle with understanding how people in different cultures  understand forms of knowledge and thinking. There are far too many animal species for us to determine their levels of thinking, especially since we heavily influence their existence and development. As far as what it means to think in general, I believe that it is a combination of all the different theories and arguments, the fact that it can be interpreted differently from person to person is proof of that.

·         Mind and Body

o   Dualism- the theory that the mind is distinct from the body

§  Real Distinction Argument- If A can clearly and distinctly be conceived apart from B, A can exist apart from B. If A can exist apart from B, A and B are really distinct. I can clearly and distinctly conceive my mind apart from my body. Therefore my mind and my body are really distinct.

o   Questioning this… Princess Elisabeth of Bohemia… How does the mind communicate its intentions to the body? Wouldn’t the body need to be a thinking thing itself in order to respond to information? And if the mind and the body are distinct, why doesn’t the body control the mind? Why is the mind so easily distracted by the wants/needs that come from the body?

o   Other questions/arguments: If my mind is distinct from my body, my particular body, couldn’t it exist independently of all bodies? … Arguably it is easier to interpret that matter in general exists apart from any minds. Could a human body exist without a mind?

o   Philosophical zombie argument- there could be a creature molecule-for-molecule identical with you, who behaves exactly as you do, but for whom there is ‘nothing going on upstairs’ ; there is nothing in the physical characterization of the human body that entails that it is conscious or it takes something specific to be ‘like’ that creature

o   “I have what is sufficient for me to know that my mind or a thinking thing exists. But that is compatible with it being true that being a body is also necessary for the existence of my mind”

o   Personal Reflection: Do you think we will one day find that the mind is nothing more than what goes on in the brain? Are you more than your brain state? I do not believe that the mind can be reduced to simply what goes on in the brain. Thinking about the future of technology and arguments about intelligence within machines, I do not believe that this technology could have a full mind without a brain, because it would take a being with a brain to create these things and program them to mimic some characteristics of the brain and mind. I think the mind, body, and brain are all completely intertwined and connected, especially when thinking about humans and our emotional reactions to things; feelings such as joy, anger, and sadness occur as our minds react to variables in our environment, and often our bodies produce reactions such as crying or smiling, when receiving commands from the brain. It is hard for me to believe that these things could exist in absence of each other, rather they present themselves in different ways.



[1] A statement is pragmatically consistent if there are clear contexts where it would be reasonable to assert it

Comments

Post a Comment