Week 3 Post 1

Philosophy and Critical Thinking Module 3: God-Thinking About Higher Things (Notes)

Key Questions: What is the relationship between religion and ethics? //  How have philosophers sought to justify belief in God? // Can the existence of horrendous evil be reconciled with the existence of God?

àphilosophy of religion is useful for developing and practicing reasoning skills

·         Philosophy and Religion (Talk with UCLA Professor Calvin Normore)

o   Historical connection- it is thought to be philosophers who were the first people to bring up the idea of monotheistic religion

o   Thinking about religion must be distinguished from thinking within religion

o   Philosophers study religions and what goes on within them, how it applies to life

o   Religion has been an important part of the history of thinking about morality—people have believed that without the idea of heaven or hell, there was no good reason to have morality

o   Divine command theory of ethics- the thought that what’s obligatory is what a god or divine something commands and what’s forbidden is what such a being forbids

§  These ideas are not about good vs evil but obligatory vs forbidden (more set in stone, dictated)

o   Relationship between Greek philosophers & Greek gods

o   (Kant) thought that you don’t need a divine legislator because reason could legislate itself

§  Not good vs evil rather whether or not it would be irrational to act in accordance with said principles

§  The categorical imperative- you should act on principles such that you could will that anybody in your situation act on them

§  Reason is replacing the divine legislator

o   Philosophers have spent eons trying to prove that God exists

o   Metaphysical Arguments vs. Pragmatic Arguments

o   Ontological arguments- rely on the fundamental thought that there are characteristics of anything that would count as a god such that it would be inconceivable that something with those characteristics could exist

§  Counterargument- the notion of perfection is not quite clear, what is perfection

o   Cosmological arguments- the thought that what we ordinarily encounter is not self-explanatory and thus requires an explanation—ultimately leads to something that does not need any further explanation

§  Counterargument- why does the world we live in have to be finite

o   Design arguments- theres a particular feature of things you encounter that could not occur by chance—there is a structure and complex interaction that could not just occur, it must have been designed—only something divine could create such complexities

§  Counterargument- evolutionary theory; things evolve and go through many stages before they come to the terms of complexity

o   What about natural evils, human evils, horrendous evils?

§  Human evils are a byproduct of having beings with freewill

·         Counter- why would a god create such creatures who could do such things? Why would they it create conditions in which those things could occur?

o   Probability theory- 16th century invention, important turning point in the history of philosophy in religion, helps ask the question is there a way it connects with questions of beliefs?

§  Two different kinds of reason? A reason for the content of the belief and a reason for holding the belief

o   If God exists, will God reward you just for believing in them?

·         The Euthyphro Problem

o   Philosophical questions- questions about the fundamental nature or essence of a thing and the answer has to be generalizable to all instances of the kind being investigated

o   Divine Command Theory of Morality- actions are right or wrong depending on whether they are loved and commanded by God or not

§  Polytheistic religions problem—what if different Gods love different things?

§  Monotheistic religions problem—what if God loves one thing at one time and despises it at another? Would that mean that some actions are both right and wrong?

§  Euthyphro- what all the Gods love is pious, what all the Gods hate is impious

o   Argument from analogy: P1. x and y have similar properties a, b, and c P2. x has property d P3. it is likely that y has property d

o   Socrates says Euthyphro’s problem is this: 1. “being loved” is a relational property; morality does not have an obvious relational structure 2. The order of explanation is backwards 3. The god’s choices are arbitrary

o   Discussion: If a god or gods exist, can they be subject to an external moral code that they themselves did not create? And if they did create it, does it make sense that they would be immoral if they chose to ignore it? I think that it would be unjust for a God or Gods to create a moral code and not abide by it, but it also seems unjust for them to create a moral code in the first place. If Gods are immortal beings of perfection, how would they know the day to day choices that a mortal human being would have to make? It seems odd to say that they would know the things a human could encounter without actually living the life they live, even as an omniscient being. It is for these reasons that I believe moral codes are more something that you choose to abide by perhaps with the guidance of teachings from Gods or a God, or historical dilemmas that societies have faced, but overall I do not think one being could create a moral code for all other beings to follow, whether they are a God or not.

·         Metaphysical Arguments for God’s Existence

o   Existence isn’t a predicate[1], rather it’s a condition for having such any properties in the first place (Kant)

o   Ontological argument- concerns being, or what exists fundamentally

§  (St. Anseim 1033-1109)

§  begins by supposing that what you are trying to prove is false, and proceeds to draw a contradiction or absurdity, showing that what you are trying to prove is in fact not absurd

o   The ontological argument for God’s existence…

Premise 1

Premise 2

Premise 3

Premise 4

Premise 5

Conclusion

God does not exist.

God exists in the understanding.

 

God is that than which no greater being can be perceived.

A being greater than God can be conceived, namely, one who exists.

Therefore, a being greater than which none greater can be conceived can be conceived. (Contradiction).

 

Therefore, God necessarily exists

 

o   If the ontological argument works for God, theoretically it should work for anything that we think of as perfect

o   Theory of intentionality- to be thinking there must be some object, actual or not, that is what you are thinking about

o   Cosmological argument- begin with observations of natural processes

§  To avoid stopping at an arbitrary point, we have to stop at a cause that is powerful enough to explain the whole casual sequence

§  It is not the argument that there has to be a first cause in time

§  It is the argument that there has to be a logically prior cause to natural causes—one with the power to cause itself—to explain how any other cause without this power qualifies as a cause

§  àThe idea of God is exactly the idea of something so powerful, there is no further cause which needs explanation for its existence

§  Critical questions: Why suppose by causal explanations that terminate in brute facts are deficient? Why suppose that ordinary causal explanations always end in infinite regress?

o   Teleological argument- argument from intelligent design ; the world is not composed of a chaotic sequence of events, but exhibits regularity and order

§  Tends to ignore any irregularity

Premise 1

Premise 2

Premise 3

Premise 4

Conclusion

Natural (non-human) processes are purposeful

Only human actions are the result of human purposes

If natural (non-human) processes do not have purposes, then some supernatural being must be the source of the purposes for which they act

This supernatural intelligence is God

Therefore, God exists

o   Discussion:  Do you think that the existence of God should rely on logical arguments? If not, then what is the value of a logical argumentation?

·         Pragmatic Arguments for God’s Existence

o   Pragmatic Argument- draws its conclusions on the basis of whether or not the beliefs or actions it recommends are useful or fulfilling an agent’s goals or purposes

o   Pascal’s Wager/critique- even if the probability that God exists is very lowàthe potential payoff—infinite, eternal bliss—is large enough to warrant in believing in God ; the payoff for not believing in God if God does exist is infinite pain and miseryàseems even more rational to believe in God than not

§  As long as you have a reason to have a certain kind of belief, it doesn’t matter how you get the belief

§  Assumes that there is only 1 god, but some religions recognize multiple gods, which would make it more complex to make a rational decision

o   Discussion- Do you think Pascal's wager negates a sincere search for truth about God? Why or why not?

·         The Problem of EvilàHow can we reconcile the existence of a merciful God with the existence of evil?

o   The idea of evil suggests that God is not powerful enough to stop it, doesn’t know about it in order to stop it, or doesn’t care to stop it

o   How cogent is this argument? 1. It assumes that evil exists (premise5) & that god is responsible for it (premise6)

§  Argument: God causes goodness and light, evil happens in his absence, he cannot help his absence

o   The Free Will Defense- evil acts are a necessary byproduct of a world containing free and morally responsible agents, and that is surely a better world than one containing no choices and people who robotically always prefer good

§  This defense only concerns evils caused by human actions; the justification for natural evil would require a separate argument

o   Questions: What kind of freedom would it be if one never actually strayed from the good? If we cannot choose freely unless we can choose evil, are we really free? If we must actually choose evil on occasion to be free and morally responsible agents, why do we need the capacity to choose evils of such horrendous consequence?

§  Non-rhetorical questions, genuinely open questions

o   The problem of evil poses an ongoing challenge for philosophers seeking to bridge morality and religion



[1] something that is affirmed or denied concerning an argument of a proposition

Comments

Post a Comment