Week 5 Post 1


·                   Scientific Realism

o   Idealism- the view that the world is composed of mental images or ideas

o   Realism- the view that the world exists independently of our minds and that we can discover this mind-independent reality through scientific investigation

o   Discussion: The physicist Werner Heisenberg famously said "what we see is not nature itself, but nature exposed to our method of questioning".  Do you think we see nature as it really is? And what does 'as it really is' mean?

o   Scientific Realism- the view that the world is just as our best scientific theories describe it to be

§  The observable entities that scientific theories recognize, any unobservable entities that they posit[1], and the explanations offered as to how the two interrelate must be accepted

§  What we experience and think about when we investigate nature is richer than what the senses deliver

§  The concepts that come from our experience and form the bases of our hypotheses are added to what sensory experience delivers

§  Concepts or terms for unobservable entities refer to mind-independent objects or natural kinds

§  Contrast with instrumentalist views (hold that the terms of scientific theories that purport[2] to refer to unobservable entities either do not denote anything or cannot be known to denote anything)

§  Problems arise when theories are overturned or shown to be false (which, historically, is the norm rather than the exception)

·         Anti-realism

o   Anti-realists adopt a skeptical attitude towards claims by realists that science has discovered realms of unobservable entities

o   Instrumentalists- hold that terms for unobservable entities do not denote anything but are retained within theories because of their instrumental value in organizing data and enabling predictions

o   Ontology- part of metaphysics, concerned with the fundamental categories of being or existence

·         Problem of Induction

o   Induction is an important form of reasoning in empirical investigation in relation to matters of fact

o   Every time we infer from some observation of a sample of a population to some conclusion about the population as a whole, we are using inductive reasoning

o   The conclusions drawn from inductive reasoning are probabilistic—they do not follow by necessity from the truth of the premises

o   Examples of ordinary inductive inferences:

§  From observations of individual cases to universal generalizationsà ex: “the crows I have examined to date are black, therefore, all crows are black”

§  From general premises to particular conclusionsàex: “all the crows which I have examined to date have been black, therefore, the next crow I see will be black”

§  From particular premises to particular conclusionsàex: “the grandparents of this crow were black and the parents of this crow were black, therefore, the offspring of this crow will be black”

o   Each of the above cases has a built-in assumption that nature exhibits a high degree of regularity

·         Hume on Causation

o   Post hoc ergo propter hoc- After this, therefore because of this  -- (a fallacy) just because one thing follows from another, doesn’t man it caused the other

§  Ex: A black cat walked in front of me, and five minutes later I tripped over and broke my ankle. Black cats really do bring bad luck!

o   Instrumentalism- the claim that the value of something is determined by how useful it is

o   Hume thought that regarding causation as nothing more than a statistical regularity was sufficient for all practical purposes    (many modern philosophers agree)

§  Limitations: Can causations be analyzed in terms of statistical regularities? Some causes appear to be irregular or imperfect; some regularities don’t seem to be causes; some regularities are difficult to separate in time

o   Discussion: Do the problems of causation really play a part in our daily lives? Or is it just one for the philosophers?

o   Importance of causation: it is involved in giving day-to-day explanations and making predictions—the causal connections between things are what scientists and medical researchers are in the business of discovering—when we make public policies or laws, we are assuming that they will have certain effects

o   Causation is an unobservable relation



[1] A statement which is made on the assumption that it will prove to be true

[2] Appear or claim to be or do something, especially falsely; profess

Comments