Week 6 Post 1

Philosophy and Critical Thinking Module 5: Moral & Political Philosophy (notes)

·         “Philosophers Talk” with Calvin Normore (UCLA Professor)

o   Moral philosophy- the study of reasons people might or might not have for doing various things that other people regard as moral

o   Moral philosophy

§  Some philosophers argue that morality is itself a social invention

§  Other philosophers argue that it is ‘pre-social’ meaning it is a fundamental feature of morality

§  Morality helps people understand why they themselves make decisions; without it, actions would be purely luck

o   Three main theoretical approaches: Utilitarianism, Kantianism, Virtue Ethics

§  What are we evaluating? How are we evaluating it?

·         Essentially we are evaluating people, actions, states of affairs as “good or bad”

·         ‘the train problem’

o   Social & Political philosophy

§  Are there ‘rights’? What are they? What does it mean to have them? How are the exercised?

§  Socialism, communism, ideas of what a ‘state’ is, and different interpretations/levels of these concepts

§  Sen’s paradox

§  Relationship to different theories of human nature & wants and control , how does the culture or ‘state’ shape people?

o   “If you don’t understand something, you take a big risk when trying to change it”

·         Utilitarianism

o   Definition: Consequentialist moral theory which evaluates the consequences of an action to judge its moral worth (rightness or wrongness)

o   Coined by Jeremy Bentham

§  Anything pleasurable is good, anything painful is bad

§  What matters the most is the net amt of pleasure generated from everybody concerned

§  Most net pleasure – any overall pain = right action

§  Hedonistic value & maximizing overall good

§  Hedonic Calculus: evaluates consequences of different possible actions

§  Measured by: intensity, duration, certainty, nearness, fruitfulness, purity, extent

o   Higher & Lower Pleasures (John Stuart Mill)

§   not think all pleasures are equal

§  Higher: pursuit of knowledge, reading, engaging in moral problems, creativity, aesthetics

§  Lower: eating, drinking, physical affection, warm bed

§  Lower pleasures in life could not generate as much good as the higher pleasures

o   Problems: The Hero’s self-sacrifice (one must die so that others may live) ; The Trolley (hit & kill 5 people by doing nothing, or hit & kill 1 person by doing something) ; Real-World (things often do not turn out as we think they should)

o   Discussion: If we think utilitarianism has merit, how can we make accurate judgements about the quality of others' subjective experiences?

·         Deontology

o   An ethical theory which argues we ought to judge something as good or bad based on the action itself rather than the consequences of that action

o   Actions, not consequences, are right or good and wrong or bad

o   Through the use of reason we discover the moral truth of our actions rather than create them

o   Categorical Imperative (Immanuel Kant)

  1. Formula of Universal Law of Nature : tries to discover maxims or rules that can be applied to everyone

2. Humanity Formula/Principle of Ends : always treat humanity as an end and not merely as a means; to treat someone as an end is to treat them as an autonomous and free agent capable of making their own decisions and following the moral law, to treat someone as a means is to disregard their freedom in deciding what to do (also applies to the individual)

3. Kingdom of Ends Formula : while we must accept that we will never reach the ideal  state, we must  always act as though we will, and so only formulate maxims that seek to achieve this goal

o   Problem: Exceptionless rules… our imperatives should be more specific, ex: ‘never lie, unless that lie would directly save a life’

o   Discussion: Do you think that having a rational argument for "doing the right thing" is enough motivation to do it? Why or why not?

·         Virtue Ethics

o   Looks at the character of an individual and asks ‘are they a good person?’

o   Plato- dikaiosune (the ideal state), primarily concerned with justice, a just society is the best possible society (achieve the best possible life)

§  3 classes: Economic (produce & consume), Guardian (intellectual elites), Auxiliary (defenders)

§  Individual guided by 3 parts of the soul: Desire (driving force—economic class), Spirit (controls desire—auxiliary class), Reason (directs & controls spirit—guardian class)

o   Aristotle- Eudaimonia: A good life

§  Context-dependent view of virtues

§  Eudaimonia (happiness)

§  Doctrine of the Mean: an attempt to understand what responses are appropriate under different conditions

§  Every emotion has its place, none are either good or bad, it is dependent on the situation   

o   Discussion: To what extent can we give virtue ethics any rational force if it gives us no objective way of deciding which actions are right or wrong?

·         Trolley Problems, Ethical Dilemmas, & Existentialism

o   Our existence precedes our essence (Jean-Paul Sartre)

§  There is no human nature for us to conform to

§  His ideas of existentialism are rooted in atheism- there is no god or creator, so human beings are responsible for who they are and what they become

o   Albert Camus- the relation between the human and the world is absurd

§  We strive to know the universe, while also being aware at all times that the universe is unknowable

§  Faith in a higher power is an escape from the absurd, and should be avoided at all costs, because it only hides the true nature of reality (the same goes for atheism as well—we cannot ever know whether a god exists)

o   Analytic thought- empiricism, rationalism, & other related theories

o   Continental though- existentialism, phenomenology, & other related theories

o   Pragmatism is squarely in the middle of these ideologies

§  We have no absolute knowledge and could be proven wrong at a later date

Comments