Week 7 Post 1

Feminist Philosophy

o   Distinction between sex & gender

§  Sex- the biological makeup up the individual (male, female, or intersex)

§  Gender- one’s social identity (masculinity, femininity, everything in between)

o   For the ancient Greeks, the binary male/female is also the mind/body divide or the spiritual/physical divide

§  Men were seen as rational beings, nearly god-like, who change the world as they see fit, their faculty of reason puts them above other animals as they transcend earthly, mortal form through reason

§  Women are not attached to the gods but the earth, they are earthly beings; one with nature, representation of physical beauty, give birth & nurture their young

o   Contemporary ideas of sex and gender have moved further away from the binary lens, understanding that it is a spectrum

o   18th & 19th centuries

§  Modern ideas of feminism began developing in the writings of theorists & activists

CONTEXT

§  Masculine traits (dominant)- strength, resilience, power, and individuality

§  Feminine traits (submissive)- emotion, softness, empathy, kindness (seen as fairer & weaker)

§  Men were masculine, women were feminine

§  Questions asked by early feminists where whether these roles were justified; discussions of nature vs. nurture, were women naturally biologically feminine, or is femininity a result of social conditioning

§  Men were autonomous individuals and had the rights & obligations of full citizens

§  Women did not live in the world as full autonomous and individual, they were communally minded

Feminist Theories

§  Mary Wollstonecraft- there is nothing inherently different about men and women; feminine traits were learnt through education

·         Believed that the right education would allow women to exhibit the “masculine” traits & ideals, which were something everyone should strive for

·         Main idea: men & women are fundamentally the same

§  Catherine Beecher- men and women are different but there should be more value brought to a woman’s role in society

·         Women are unique in there capability to possess feminine traits

·         Women should stay in the home to practice these traits, developing them in children, and to keep men morally pure

·         Men protected the world

·         Women had Christ-like virtues that they must teach their men and children—they were the moral & physical center of the family unit

·         Main idea: the role of women is just as important as the role of men

o   20th Century

§  Simone De Beauvoir

·         Existentialist and phenomenological feminist, philosopher, writer

·         Existentialism- concerned with the lived experience of the individual (first-person account of [the act of] being or living)

·         Phenomenology- concerned with the particular physicality that corresponds with all lived experience (explores the idea that all being occurs in physicality)

·         Gender norms are socially constructed, but there is a fundamental difference between men and women; their physicality—which makes their experiences different

·         Sought to disconnect femininity with female and masculinity with male

·         Sex and gender are different

·         White, middle class man is seen as the norm

·         Main idea: men and women are different, but one is not better than the other

·         Acknowledges (more recently) that the traditional image of the autonomous rational individual is always male, thus women are defined in relation to the man, not on their own—this is how it was in her day (1940s/50s) but it does not need to stay this way

§  Care-Focused Feminist Approaches

·         An alternative way of thinking about philosophy & ethics

·         The traditional structure of ethics values the predominately masculine traits of autonomy, individuality, freedom, and liberty

·         The purpose of most ethical systems is to empower the individual to act in the world and seek their idea of a good life

·         Care-focused ethics argue for a more communal-based approach to thinking ethically—good life can only be found by understanding and striving for others goods as well as our own

·         Prominent theorists: Carol Gilligan & Nel Noddings

§  Liberal Feminism                                                                                                        

·         Concerned with social norms & formal laws

·         What keeps women in a subordinate position is the social structures we have in place

§  Intersectionality

·         One of the most controversial topics within western civilization

·         Many feminists of the past sought to discuss the ‘position of women’ and could therefore only account for their own perspective

·         Intersectionality seeks to identify the individual based on all their various intersecting identifiers

·         Decentralizes different social groups

Comments