Week 8 Post 1

 Social Contract Theory

o   A political theory, one way to organize society

o   A clear and unambiguous way of discussing the rights and responsibilities of each individual within society

o   We forgo a certain amount of freedom when we decide to live in a society, but this sacrifice leads to a better life for all

o   Lists rights & obligations for each member of the community

o   Common factor of all theories: human beings are rational, free, equal individuals

Thomas Hobbes—the State of Nature

§  Self-interest; no community groups, friendships, or family

§  No inherent good or evil, just desire and aversion

§  No one benefits…any society is better than this

§  This is why we restrict ourselves to a social contract

§  Someone whose ruling is unquestionable must be in charge

§  Unwavering loyalty to whoever is in charge is necessary for the survival of society

§  Social contract is the only thing keeping us from maniac violence and destruction

John Locke—Honest & True

§  People are inherently moral

§  We should be able to pursue our own conception of the ‘good life’ as long as we don’t interfere with anyone else’s conception of it

§  We do not need a social order to control and restrict us

§  The problems arise when the population increases

§  A governing body is necessary to decide over disputes between individuals, esp. those regarding land

§  Negative liberty rather than positive liberty

Jean-Jaques Rousseau—State of Nature = Source of Misery

§  Inequalities arose from division of labor & property laws/taxes

§  Social contract tore humanity away from peaceful way of nature

§  We cannot go back to how things were, we must fix the inequalities within the social contract

John Rawls

§  How we create and implement the social contract is important, not how we formalize the hypothetical state of nature (aka the original position)

§  Each person has different views of the good life & different ideas about how society should be structured

§  The social contract is focused less on the individual and more on ensuring everyone is accounted for

§  Social contract should benefit everyone, not just those in a position of power or wealth

§  His original position is the only one situated within the real world

§  Recognizes the inequalities due to everyone not having the same access to resources

§  The difference principle: those who have the least should have access to the most assistance, to ensure equity

§  Social contract is written and agreed to by a representation of individuals within the society; maximize resources, services, and facilities for the least advantageous populations

§  The Veil of Ignorance: a conceptual tool that can alleviate the issue of different social groups clashing over the distribution of resources

·         Ensures the representative individuals writing the social contract are not aware of their own personal social standing

·         The state in which a just & fair society can be created

·         Should happen because individuals are often unaware of their own perceptions of others in society

·         Reflective Questions: What rights or duties might come out of a social contract like this? // Is the veil of ignorance practical? // What does it mean to have a representative group constructing the social contract of everyone is under the veil of ignorance? // Wouldn’t everyone under the veil of ignorance come to a similar outcome? Does this mean justice is objective? //

 

 

Political Philosophy

o   Capitalism- the means of production and distribution of goods are privately owned--Individuals can own property and restrict its use to however they desire

o   Socialism- people still own things, property still exists-capital goods are owned by the state for the good of the community

o   Communism-eliminates the idea of private property-all things owned by all people

§  Marx: communism is the desirable end state of society, capitalism is not sustainable so societies must use socialism to move to communist ideals

§  Have yet to see a communist state, b/c states who claim to be communist are still in the socialist stage

o   Emerged in response to libertarianism

Anarchism

·         There is no legitimate political authority

·         Legitimate political authority- the ability to necessitate an obligation from the members of a community to follow the rule of law

·         A political framing device, asks: on what authority does a political system govern?

·         Two kinds: critiquing & restructuring political states (contingent anarchist state) & dismantling political states (absolutist anarchist state)

Libertarianism

·         Values individual freedom above all else

·         Foundational principle:  self-ownership

·         Libertarian state is a minimal state whose powers are limited

·         Conceptions of justice mostly focused on limiting coercion

·         States only authority is ability to force individuals to not interfere with rights of other citizens

·         Each individual is free & equal and owes nothing to the state; states owe nothing to individual other than protection from coercion

·         Ensures equality but not equity

·         Greatly values property rights

·         Economic system resembles individual rights

·         Support free & open market

·         Businesses are autonomous & can engage in any sort of consensual activity without the state interfering

Capitalism

·         Supports libertarianism

·         Individuals own the means of production and distribution

·         Those who own capital goods get to decide what they make, where they sell it, & what they sell it for

·         Individuals (who own capital goods) moral values often influence decisions

·         People have no say in how individuals [who own capital goods] use them

Socialism

·         Designed to prevent inequality by moving away from libertarian freedom & putting more emphasis on equity

·         Removal of private ownership over capital goods in favor of communal or state ownership

·         Means & distribution of goods are communally controlled & operated (rather than individually)

·         An attempt to right the wrongs of capitalism (Marx)

·         Private property still exists

Capitalist, Socialist, & Communist Democracies

·         Not competing political structures that oppose each other—economic systems that can all function in different political climates

·         All three systems function at their best under a democratic political system

·         Capitalist Democracy: freedom above all, individuals own property & means of production & distribution, minimal individual duties & obligations, rights secured by negative liberty

·         Socialist Democracy: values equity above freedom, interested in ensuing each individual is accounted for, means of production & distribution are controlled by community or state, more even power distribution, democratic process ensures those in positions of power are always led by wants & needs of community, more individual duties & obligations, responsibility of everyone to ensure community success

·         Communist Democracy: (mostly theoretical), dictates the need for every voice to be heard

·         Key Questions: What examples are there of capitalism, socialism, or communism in the world? // Can a nation be some combination of these three economic systems? // What might that look like? // Are any of these the ideal state, or are there inherent flaws?

Comments