Week 12 Post 1

 Incorporating Philosophy & Critical Thinking in Schools

·         https://critical-thinking.project.uq.edu.au/

·         in classrooms, the concepts of philosophy are not as important as the practice of it

·         in philosophy & reasoning classrooms students learn by working together

o   community of learners

o   students do most of the thinking and decision making for their learning

·         principles of clarity and charity

o   principle of clarity- aim to be as clear with your thinking and communication as possible

o   principle of charity- to engage with the best person of another person’s argument or idea, regardless of whether you agree with them or not… forces us to engage meaningfully with other people’s thinking and rigorously consider our own

o   helps us become more reasonable while developing a deeper understanding of the topic under investigation

·         to be a philosophy and reason student is to explore the worth of a claim through the lens of logic and reasoning

·         Reflection and Revision

o   when we critically interrogate ideas and carefully reflect upon our understanding, in many instances, we come to realize that our beliefs are flawed, or at the very least are in need of further refinement……its hard to find public figures who model this behavior

o   the willingness to modify one’s thinking when presented with more compelling evidence is one of the key signs of a critical thinker

·         Ways of Writing

o   discuss and evaluate decisions as writers in order to improve how we approach and engage with the writing process and thinking that sits behind it

o   explicitly identify what the text aims to achieve and who we are writing for

o   Typical Philosophy & Reason Essay key parts

§  Evaluates the validity of an argument

·         Establishes whether the argument is deductively valid, invalid or inductive in nature & explains significance

·         Considers counterarguments

§  Content and specific structure varies based on the task at hand and the writer’s individual decisions

§  Clear thesis

§  Provides explicit definitions for key terms (helps the reader understand exactly what we are talking about)

§  Refers to premises or conclusion throughout the essay

§  Synthesizes key points in a conclusion

·         Ways of Talking

o   When sharing an insight, responding to a question, or participating in class discussion, address your comments to the entire class as opposed to just the teacher

§  Indicates to other students in the room that you are interested in hearing their perspective and opens up the conversation to receive feedback from a wider audience

o   Shared language

§  “I believe X because” …….. “My reasons for this belief are…”

§  Conversations follow a logical thread

§  “I’d like to build upon that point,” ………. “Further to what ___ was saying…” ……… “Similarly, I believe that…”

§  “While I hear what you are saying, I would argue that” …….. “Another point to consider is…” etc etc

o   Value of disagreement- Tests our beliefs & modifies our viewpoints

o   The power of example- Makes explanations easier to follow and helps ensure that the lines of communication and understanding and function more effectively

·         Ways of Feedback

o   Clarity- ensures audience understands what we mean, allows for more effective shared discussion

o   Precision- specific and intentional with language, avoids miscommunication

o   Accuracy- Content of statement holds true to the facts of the world, guarantees the shared understandings of the world we built are not constructed on misinformation

o   Relevance- choose information or reasons that relate directly to the main point, eliminates distracting, confusing, or irrelevant information, allows for a more clear and coherent line of thought  

o   Significance- concerned with the most important aspects and explaining their importance, put this at the forefront of what you are communicating, ensures that we focus on the most important ideas rather than possible providing distracting ones

o   Depth- addresses relevant counterarguments, explains relevance, gives worked examples, pushes us to move beyond a superficial understanding

o   Breadth- considers a diverse range of information relevance to our thinking and communication, ensures we do not ignore key ideas that are relevant

o   Coherence- articulate thoughts logically and without contradiction allows us to think about and communicate ideas in an order that makes sense

Comments