Week 9 Post 1

 

Key Questions: Are my subjective experiences similar to those of others? // Can we be more confident in our knowledge claims through working collaboratively? // In what ways does social collaboration verify or improve our knowledge claims? // What does a theory do? // How can we tell which law is operating, or which rule is being followed at any time? // Do our brains work individually to give us the best outcomes of our inquiries? // What are some of the common mistakes in the ways that we reason? // How does science institutionalize, or organize, some of the advantages of collective reasoning? // What is this thing called ‘falsification’? //Why is bad science unethical?

 

·         Intersubjectivity: the idea of building and understanding based on similar subjective experiences between individuals; one way we can socially create & verify knowledge

o   Importance: allows us to be more confident that there is some kind of reality behind our subjective experiences

o   Discussion: To what extent do you think the similar behavior of other people in response to stimuli indicates the same subjective experience? Or is the phrase ‘same subjective’ a contradiction in terms?

o   Learning how to think critically and philosophically is learning how to follow three basic norms of good thinking:

§  1. Norm of reasonableness: Form beliefs on the basis of evidence (reasons, facts, good arguments)

§  2. Norm of coherence: avoid inconsistency

§  3. Principle of Charity: Always present the strongest interpretation of an argument before developing a counterargument

o   Rationality, risibility, or ridicule have interrelated functions and are each distinctively human traits

o   Philosophy is a practice of subjecting one’s beliefs and actions to rational scrutiny

§  It can be confronting because one must re-examine the beliefs that they may hold dear

o   These things can help improve our generalizations

o   The benefit of working with others to build knowledge is that we can gain access to their wisdom & experience & subject our own ideas to scrutiny

o   Discussion: Human progress seems more than ever to depend on people working together to discover new knowledge and find better ways of doing things. Do you think there is still room for the individual ‘genius’ to contribute to human advancement? How does this compare with the past?

Comments